Crisis Management

Member states engage in crisis management, both in their immediate neighbourhood and globally, through various multilateral institutions. While the EU itself is now the primary stabilising force across the Balkans, NATO remains the primary conduit for European efforts in Afghanistan, and the EU turned to the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) to deploy a police mission during the Kyrgyz crisis. Meanwhile, in African crises European governments typically engage in indirect crisis management, providing financial and diplomatic support to the United Nations (UN) and African Union (AU). This fragmentation is reflected in the assessments included here. European governments have staked far greater resources and taken much greater political risks in places where troops, police or civilian crisis experts are deployed through the EU or NATO. But since the EU frequently states its support for UN and OSCE operations in high-profile trouble spots such as Sudan and Kyrgyzstan, they must also be included in any assessment of Europe’s contribution to crisis management.

A small number of European governments – France, the UK and, to some extent, Germany – play a crucial role in defining not only EU and NATO policy but also the governance of the UN and the OSCE. The European Commission has also been an essential donor to the AU’s peace operations. The activities of these organisations are an important but overlooked dimension of European power, even if they do not fly a European flag or involve many European personnel. We have also covered European activities ranging from conflict prevention (as in West Africa) to long-term statebuilding (as in Kosovo). With the all-important exception of Afghanistan, neither the EU nor NATO is at present directly involved in “hot” crises involving significant conflict. Instead, European efforts are largely focused on averting violence and, in particular, on long-term post-conflict peacebuilding.

READ THE FULL ARTICLE - COMPARE TO 2012

 

 

Conflict prevention and mediation - Grade: B-
Category Unity Resources Impact Total Grade
54 - Crisis management in the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia 2/5 3/5 5/10 10/20 B-
55 – Crisis Management in Sudan and Chad 4/5 3/5 4/10 11/20 B-
56 – Crisis management in West Africa 3/5 3/5 4/10 10/20 C+

 

Humanitarian action and intervention - Grade: B-
Category Unity Resources Impact Total Grade
57 – Response to the earthquake in Haiti 4/5 4/5 8/10 16/20 A-
58 – Response to flooding in Pakistan 3/5 3/5 5/10 11/20 B-
59 – Response to the humanitarian crisis in Gaza 4/5 3/5 3/10 10/20 C+

 

Peacemaking and peacekeeping operations - Grade: B-
Category Unity Resources Impact Total Grade
60 – Stabilisation in Georgia 5/5 4/5 6/10 15/20 B+
61 – Crisis management in Kyrgyzstan 4/5 1/5 1/10 6/20 C-
62 – Crisis management in Somalia 4/5 4/5 5/10 13/20 B

 

State building and nation building - Grade: B-
Category Unity Resources Impact Total Grade
63 – Stabilisation and state building in Afghanistan 2/5 4/5 3/10 9/20 C+
64 –  Stabilisation and state building in  Iraq 5/5 2/5 4/10 11/20 B-
65 –  Stabilisation and state building in Bosnia and Hezegovina 4/5 4/5 5/10 13/20 B
66 – Stabilisation and state building in Kosovo 3/5 4/5 5/10 12/20 B-
67 –  Stabilisation and state building in Congo 4/5 3/5 4/10 11/20 B-


 


The Scorecard in the Press

World Huanqiu
03 Apr 14

ECFR's Scorecard is used in an analysis of Polish foreign policy

Estudios de Política Exterior
12 Mar 14

José I. Torreblanca and Borja Lasheras analize the Spanish foreign policy in the Scorecard…

Money.pl
10 Feb 14

Money.pl presents the latest ECFR Scorecard publication.

Money.pl
10 Feb 14

Money.pl presents the latest ECFR Scorecard publication.

RTVE
10 Feb 14

Borja Lasheras comments on the European Foreign Policy Scorecard on Spanish National Radio

Affari Italiani
10 Feb 14

The Scorecard 2014 on Affari Italiani 

Il Velino
10 Feb 14

The Italian press agency Il Velin on Scorecard 2014 

Il Foglio
07 Feb 14

Europe and Scorecard on Il Foglio

Tribuna Politica
06 Feb 14

The 2014 Scorecard on Tribuna Politica

Read more press >