The European Council on Foreign Relations

Facing disaster in Iran, Europe must finally make the hard choices

By Timothy Garton Ash - 01 Nov 07


The EU waffles while Washington and Tehran move towards war. Yet Europe has a big stick if it is willing to use it

This article originally appeared in The Guardian

Europe is slouching towards another foreign policy disaster on the scale of Iraq. This disaster is called Iran. It comes in two variants. Variant one is that the US bombs Iran before George Bush leaves the White House in January 2009. Variant two is that Iran acquires a nuclear bomb. Most Europeans are hyper-alert to the first danger and blind to the second. We should be acting now, urgently and decisively, to fend off both. Instead, we are sleepwalking to a cliff's edge.

I don't need to spell out the manifold perils of military action nor, I hope, to emphasise that no moral equivalence between Tehran and Washington is implied. But why don't we also grasp the other danger? A quarter of a century ago millions of people flooded through the streets of Bonn, London and Rome to protest against the deployment of American nuclear missiles - and even against civilian nuclear power. ("Atomkraft? Nein, Danke.") Now a fissiparous, unstable and increasingly militarised Islamic regime, whose president has called for Israel to be removed from the map, is deliberately proceeding towards the threshold where it could, if it chose, swiftly take the last step to having a nuclear weapon. Among the probable consequences would be a nuclear arms race in the Middle East, with Sunni Muslim powers such as Saudi Arabia deciding they need their own.

To read the full article, click here.

 


Comments for this entry are closed.

#1

ls

First there is a short correction needed on your remark about the speech of the Iranian President. Would you please try to find out what the correct translation of his speech is? I was told that his remarks were about the removal of the face of earth of the present Isra:elian Government. Secondly, why is everyone talking about the risks of the possibele (stil not proven)Iranian energy in getting an Atomic Weapon while no one talks about the reason why Iran might want to posess such weapon. I hear no western remarks about the fact that the biggest threat for peace in the Middle East comes from a country that does not effectuate any UN resolution and keeps a complete people in hostage. This small country also seems to have more atomic weapons than any other Asian country. So stop blowing the Iranian balloon without producing any proof.  Start calling the problem by its name. The biggest threat to peace in the Middle East is Isra?l keeping Palestine occupied.
            H.Landskroon
              the Netherlands

Hans Landskroon | the Netherlands | 07 Nov 07, 07 Nov 07 EST
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.

Latest Publications

European Foreign Policy Scorecard 2012

How well did European foreign policy perform over the last year?

China Analysis: Facing the risks of the 'going out strategy'

From a major exporter of goods to a major exporter of capital

China Analysis: One or two Chinese models?

To Chongqing or Guangdong? China’s big development decision

Ukraine after the Tymoshenko verdict

Instead of lecturing Ukraine the EU must show that it means business

A 'reset' with Algeria: the Russia to the EU's south

Algeria is at risk of turmoil without EU-backed reform

Dealing with a post-BRIC Russia

Learning to deal with a changing Russia under a familiar leader

Rescuing the euro: what is China’s price?

What price will Europe pay for China's help in rescuing the euro?

Four scenarios for the reinvention of Europe

The impossible is also necessary if the euro and Europe are to be saved

Spain after the elections: the 'Germany of the south'?

Spain's election, caught between the euro crisis and Arab revolutions

Europe and the Arab revolutions: a new vision for democracy and human rights

The EU's role in building accountable societies in North Africa

How to stop the demilitarisation of Europe

Building sustainable EU military power at a time of defence cuts

Reinvention of Europe

In the Press

France Culture
09 Feb 12

Justin Vaïsse gives an Analysis of US presidential elections

Spravy Pravda
09 Feb 12

Spravy Pravda reviews ECFR's European Foreign Policy Scorecard 2012

Financial Times
09 Feb 12

Ulrike Guérot comments on Germany and Europe

Internazionale
09 Feb 12

José Ignacio Torreblanca pens an article on EU and no-nation States

Read more press >

Publications side bar